Which Species of Wood Will Produce the Most Thermal Energy When Combusted

Researched by Max R.
2003-04



PURPOSE

The purpose of this experiment was to find which species of wood will produce the most thermal energy when combusted. 

I became interested in this idea when some of my friends and I were on a campout with Boy Scout troop trying to get one of our friends dry after he fell into a creek. I was curious about what wood species of wood in our stock would work best. 

The information gained from this experiment help to give valuable information to citizens with wood burning stoves that require an efficient hot burning source.


HYPOTHESIS

My hypothesis was that oak would produce the most thermal energy when combusted. 

I based this hypothesis on a website that I discovered as I was gathering notes for my research report. The website stated that the denser the wood the more chemical energy it holds and therefore the more thermal energy it would produce when it was combusted. The website was 1. Heating With Wood Species, Characteristics, and Volumes G88-881-A <http://extension.usu.edu/forestery/HomeTown/Genral_Heating With Wood.Htm>


EXPERIMENT DESIGN

The constants in this study were:
* The amount of wood used for each trial
* The size of the beaker you will use to measure the amount of water for each trial
* The size of shavings you will cut the wood into for each trial
* The amount of water put into the beaker in for each trial
* The source of the ignition for the wood
* The distance between the beaker and the fire for each trial

The manipulated variable was the four different types of wood tested, spruce, hemlock, and walnut.

The responding variable was the temperature of increase the water heated in each.

To measure the responding variable you will use a thermometer to measure the temperature of the water before and after it has been heated.


MATERIALS


QUANTITY ITEM DESCRIPTION
18” by 1.5cm blocks of oak in 2” blocks
18” by 1.5cm blocks of maple in 2”blocks
18” by 1.5cm blocks of spruce in 2” blocks
18” by 1.5cm blocks of hemlock in 2” blocks
1 Box of kitchen matches
4 Regular tap water (4000mL) (may be extra) 
1 Stand to set water container on (any type)
1 Metal cookie sheet
1 Open vented room
Beaker able to hold at most 250mL of tap water 
1 Stop watch
One assistant to help with the timing.
1 Camera
1 Metal Stand (any kind)


RESULTS

The original purpose of this experiment was to find which species of wood will produce the most thermal energy when combusted. 

The results of this experiment were that maple wood produced the most temperature change in 4 minutes. Its temperature change was 52.9*C, Hemlock in second had a temperature change of 52.4*C. Oak in third had 43.0*C temperature change, and spruce had 42.0*. 

See the table and graph below. 



RESEARCH REPORT

INTRODUCTION

This report includes information about the properties of wood as used for fuel, combustion, and the heat energy produced by combustion.

PROPERTIES OF WOOD

The definition of wood is a tough substance found under the bark of trees and shrubs. There are two main categories for wood classification, hard wood and soft wood. Hard woods are deciduous trees or wide leafed trees, while soft woods are coniferous trees, which are cone bearing evergreens. Soft woods are used for construction and making paper products, while hard woods are used for producing furniture and housing materials. Hard woods are normally denser than soft woods. Every species of wood has a different pattern or design by which to distinguish it by. Wood consists of many things, 50% cellulose, 15%-30% hemicelluloses, 15%-30% lignin, and 5%-30% ash and other extractives. Denser hard woods are more likely to burn slower and hotter than less dense soft woods. Another thing is that hard woods are more likely to be more difficult to ignite because of they contain less oxygen. 

COMBUSTION

Combustion is a rapid process of burning, which produces heat and usually light. This oxidation process will occur when fuel is heated enough to produce a flammable gas. Oxygen and fuel are needed for combustion to occur combustion is also a rapid release of energy. The more oxygen that is consumed the more heat and energy is produced. There are many types of combustion such as Thermal Combustion, Spontaneous Combustion, and Internal Combustion in engines. Combustion is an effective way to dispose of waste. 

HEAT

Heat is one of the most important forms of energy. Combustion creates heat by chemical reaction. Heat keeps us alive. One of our main sources of heat is our food, which undergoes a chemical reaction to create heat and keep our bodies temperature at a constant level. Anything that gives off heat is a heat source. There are six main heat sources, the sun, the earth, chemical reactions, nuclear energy, friction, and electricity. You can’t see heat or energy unless its in huge amounts, but you may notice its effects

BRITISH THERMAL UNIT 

A BTu is defined as the amount of energy required to increase the temperature of one pound of water at its maximum density by one degree of Fahrenheit temperature at normal atmospheric pressure. Also a BT’s are used to measure the quantities specification for energy producing or energy consuming appliances for the amount of heat they produce. One British thermal unit or BTu is equivalent to the energy found in the tip of a match. One BTu is equal to 0.25 food calories. One British thermal unit is equal to 1055.05585 Joules. 

SUMMARY

In conclusion different properties of wood affect the amount of thermal energy produced by their combustion. Different species of wood produce different amounts of heat. 

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Kuhns, Mike and Schmidt, Tom. Heating With Wood, Species, Characteristics, and
Volumes G88-881-A. Nov 25,2003
<http;//extension.usu.edu/forestery/HomeTown/Genral_HeatingWithWood.htm>

Joule Michels. “What Is A BTu?” 2/4/04

“Whatis? com”, “British thermal unit”. 2/9/04 
 http://whatis.techtarget.com/defonition/0,sid9_gci213563.00.html

“Heat Energy”World Book 2003 Deluxe Addition 1/15/04 
 CD-ROM. World Book Inc. 1997 

R.E Treybal “Combustion” Microsoft Encarta. 
 CD-ROM Encyclopedia Deluxe 2001. 

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

I would like to thank the following people for helping make my project possible:

  • My parents for helping me perform my experiment and for giving me support throughout the whole thing.
  • My science teacher, for helping me with my ideas, and if I hit a rough spot.
  • One of my friends, for helping me with methods for writing things out, and with better ways to perform various things. 


Top of page

Menu of 2003-2004 Science Projects

Back to the Selah Homepage