The Effectiveness Of Various Cleansers On Stained Teeth

Researched by Kyle M
1999-2000




PURPOSE
 

The purpose of this experiment was to determine which tooth cleaner most effectively removes stains from teeth.

I became interested in this idea when I was reading through a book that said sugar and acids demineralize and decalcify tooth enamel.  I discussed this idea with the hygienist when I went to the dentist to get my teeth cleaned.

The information gained from this experiment might be useful to dentists, dental hygienists, and companies that make tooth cleaning products.  This information also might be helpful to the general public to educate them on keeping their teeth healthy.
to top



HYPOTHESIS
 

My hypothesis is that the fluoridated toothpaste will be the best cleaner to remove stains from teeth. 

I based my hypothesis on information from dentists and magazine articles on dental care.
to top


EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN
 

 The constants in this study were the sugars (soda pop) and acid (lemon juice).  Kind of teeth, kind of cleaner, tooth brush, and same amount of time brushed.

 The manipulated variable was the substance used to clean the teeth.
 The responding variable was the whiteness of the teeth. 
 To measure the responding variable I used a coloromiter to observe the whiteness and discoloring of the teeth. 
to top


MATERIALS
MATERIALS

QUANTITYITEM DESCRIPTION

 
12                  extracted molars
12                  empty petri dishes
                     water
                     soda pop
                    lemon juice
2                 toothbrushes
1                colorimeter at Tree Top Lab
                  baking soda
                 mouthwash
                 fluoridated toothpaste
                 nonfluoridatad toothpaste
                 tartar control toothpaste
8               pairsrubber gloves
118 mL          glycerine
12            press - on labels
1            permanent marking pen

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

QUANTITY   ITEM DESCRIPTION 


PROCEDURES

1.     Make labels for the pertri dishes according to the type of stain and cleaner solution that will be  used for that tooth.
2. Put gloves on to handle teeth.
3. Pour glycerin out of jar making sure that the teeth remain in the jar. 
4. Place teeth in container of water and boil for ten  minutes.  Remove the teeth from the boiling water and dry them thoroughly. 
5. Place each tooth into correct ziplock bag according to label.
6.  Put tooth in colorimeter and record reading.  Repeat for each tooth.
7. Fill six empty petri dishes three-fourths full with only soda pop .
8. Fill six empty petri dishes three-fourths full with only lemon juice.
9. Arrange petri dishes in the order in which they appear on the recording  chart. Keep them in this order to avoid recording information incorrectly.
10. Soak each tooth in its solution for 2 weeks.
11. At the end of this period of time put on rubber gloves.
12. Remove tooth from petri dish.
13. Put stained tooth in colorimeter. 
14. Brush tooth with correct cleaner. 3 min.  Clean all surfaces equally.
15. Put tooth in colorimeter and record data.
16. Dispose of teeth and gloves at Tree Top Lab
to top


RESULTS
 The original purpose of this experiment was to determine which tooth cleaner most effectively removes stains from teeth.

 The results from my experiment indicated that tooth five had the largest amount of discoloration removed during the brushing process.  The reading of the stained color was 119.44.  The cleaned color was 63.40.  The difference between the stained and cleaned color was 56.04.
 

to top
 
 


CONCLUSION

 My hypothesis was that the fluoridated toothpaste would be the best cleaner to remove stains from teeth.
 The results indicate that this hypothesis should be rejected because the greatest amount of discoloration was removed by the non-fluoridated toothpaste.
 Because of the results of this experiment I wonder if the same results would occur with other kinds of stains, longer staining time, and other cleaning agents.
 If I were to conduct this project again I would use cow teeth instead of teeth from humans, possibly use different stains, and conduct it for a longer period of time.
to top
 
RESEARCH REPORT

 In this report you will read about tooth decay, tooth development and structure, bacteria relating to dental cavities, and preventative measures to avoid tooth decay.

Tooth Decay

 The second most common of all health disorders is tooth decay.  It is second to the common cold.  Tooth decay usually occurs in young children but it can effect any person.  Tooth decay is the leading cause of tooth loss in young people. 

 It has been shown that eighty four percent of all cavities are located on molars which are in the back of the mouth.  Molars contain many pits and grooves. It is harder to reach these areas with a toothbrush.  When these grooved areas are not properly cleaned bacteria settle on the tooth surface and use the food particles left in the mouth to create acid.  It is this acid that creates cavities.

Tooth Development and Structure

 During the early years young children have a set of twenty teeth.  These teeth are baby or deciduous teeth.  Later another set of thirty two larger teeth replace these teeth.  There are three kinds of permanent teeth:  incisors, cuspids, and molars.
 
 
 


 The tooth is made up of an external crown and a root that is anchored in the jaw.  The outer covering of the crown is made of enamel.  Enamel is a very hard substance because it contains mineral salts such as calcium.  Mineral salts are also present in saliva.  These salts in saliva help add hardness to teeth.  Underneath the enamel is dentin.  Dentin is a bonelike substance that helps form the root.

Bacteria

 Bacteria which are tiny colonies of living organisms are constantly found in the human mouth.  It is normal for millions of bacteria to be in your mouth.

 Bacteria is the number one enemy in the formation of cavities.  There are two kinds of bacteria that are quite harmful to teeth.  They are mutans streptococci and lactobacilli.  Mutans streptococci are able to grab any sugar that enters the mouth.  They use the sugar to change the pH in the mouth.  They then form acid on the teeth.  It is this acid that causes teeth to decay.  The lactobacilli are more able to survive in an acid environment.

 Bacteria changes all foods into acid.  Sugars and starches are favorites of bacteria.  Plaque is formed by bacteria, acid, food debris, and saliva.  Plaque is a sticky substance that sticks to the teeth.  Plaque is easily detected on the grooved chewing surfaces of the back molars, just above the gum line, and at the edges around fillings.  When plaque is not removed from the teeth it becomes tartar.
 

9
 There is acid in the plaque.  It is this acid that dissolves the enamel surface of the tooth and creates holes in the tooth.  Most of the bacterial activity occurs within twenty minutes after eating.  This is when the acid is most active.  The bacteria multiply faster and the plaque grows in size and thickness.  This makes it harder to wash the bacteria away with saliva. 

 Bacteria will use the sugars found in candy and other sweet foods as well as the natural sugars found in fruits and milk.  They also use the carbohydrates found in potato chips, pasta, and bread. 

 Our teeth are able to repair the damage done to the enamel by the acid in a process called remineralization.  The minerals found in the saliva try to repair the damaged areas of the tooth surface.  But, the rate of destruction of the tooth enamel by acid is much faster than the natural remineralization that occurs. 

Preventative Measures

 There are several things that can be done to prevent tooth decay.  The timing of your snacks is critical to preventing cavities.  After snacking the acid that is produced is neutralized by the saliva and is cleared from the mouth.  After the acid is removed the minerals present in saliva crystallize on the enamel and begin to repair the areas that were damaged by the acid.  The longer the interval between meals and snacks provides more opportunity for the acid to be neutralized and more time for the damage to be repaired.  When frequent snacking takes place there is a constant attack on the tooth surface by the acid.  There is also less time for tooth repair to take place. 
10
 Fluoride has been called a wonder of modern dentistry.  It incorporates itself into the enamel of the tooth and strengthens it and makes it more resistent to attacks by acid.  Fluoride works with the saliva in the mouth to restore, or remineralize the decayed spot on the tooth.  The pH level in the mouth is lower after eating.  It is during this time that fluoride is able to reduce the activity of the mutans streptococci.  Fluoride is found in many tooth cleaners as well as being applied to the teeth by the dentist at regular visits. 

 There are many toothpastes that promise better results in cleaning tooth surfaces as well as helping to control plaque growth and tartar control.  The cleaning power of a toothpaste depends on its ability to remove stains from the surface of the tooth.  Toothpastes contain gentle abrasives to help clean tooth surfaces.  Most toothpastes contain fluoride.  Some use stannous fluoride while others use sodium fluoride or sodium monofluoroshosphate.  Tartar control toothpastes contain pyrophosphates to slow the buildup of tartar above the gumline.  The most important factors to reduce the buildup of plaque on tooth surfaces is regular brushing,  twice a day and flossing to remove debris that is between the teeth.

 In this report you read about tooth decay, tooth development and structure, bacteria relating to dental cavities, and preventative measures to avoid tooth decay. 

 I hope that information will help you further your understanding about my project.
to top

BIBLIOGRAPHY

"Anatomy of a Tooth", [online] http://www.umanitaba.ca/outreach/wisdomtooth/anatomy.htm

Single, Dorthy, Dental Health. New York: Chelsea House,1994. pg 69 - 71

''Embryological Development", Encarta, 1998

http://www.encarta.msn.com/find/Concise.asp?z=1&pg=2&ti=028df000

http://www.healthy teeth.org/Cavities.html

http://lveschelabs.dent.umich.edu/

''Teeth'' Encarta, 1998

"Teeth-Encarta [online]available htt:// encarta.msn. 
com/find/concise. osp=?z=1 andpg=2andti=028DFooo

"Toothpaste and tooth power" The World Book Encyclopedia, 1999
 

http://www.saveyoursmile.com/healtharticles/cavities.html

http://www.saveyoursmile.com/parents/candy. html

http://www.saveyoursmile.com/parents/kidscavities.html

http://www.toothtalk.com/interest.html
 
 

to top


 

Menu of 1999-2000 Science Projects

Back to the Selah Homepage